Theories of Art

How to read this page: This article maps the topic from beginner to expert across six levels � Remembering, Understanding, Applying, Analyzing, Evaluating, and Creating. Scan the headings to see the full scope, then read from wherever your knowledge starts to feel uncertain. Learn more about how BloomWiki works ?

Theories of Art (What is Art?) is the "Study of the Boundary"—the investigation of what makes an "Object" (a urinal, a painting, or a symphony) "Art" rather than just a "Thing." For 2,000 years, art was defined as **"Mimesis"** (Imitating Nature). But after the 20th century, when **Marcel Duchamp** put a urinal in a gallery, the "Definition" exploded. From the "Institutional Theory" (Art is whatever the 'Art World' says it is) to the "Expression Theory" (Art is 'Emotion') and "Formalism," this field explores the "Essence of Creativity." It is the science of "Meaning-Making," explaining why a "Canvas with a single red dot" can be worth "Millions" while a "House Painting" is worth "Pennies."

Remembering

• Definition of Art — The "Necessary and Sufficient" conditions that make something an artwork.
• Mimesis — The "Classical" theory: Art is "Imitation" or "Copying" of reality.
• Expressionism (Tolstoy) — The theory that art is the "Communication of Emotion" from the artist to the audience.
• Formalism (Bell) — The theory that art is "Significant Form": the "Arrangement" of lines, colors, and shapes, regardless of what they represent.
• The Institutional Theory (Dickie/Danto) — The radical idea that art is a "Social Status" given to an object by "The Art World" (Critics, Curators, Galleries).
• The Intentionalist Theory — Art is an object made with the "Intention" of being art.
• Aesthetic Theory — Art is an object designed to provide an "Aesthetic Experience" (Beauty/Awe).
• Cluster Theory (Gaut) — The view that art "Doesn't have one definition," but a "Cluster of Traits" (e.g., 'Skill,' 'Imagination,' 'Emotion').
• Anti-Essentialism (Weitz) — The claim that "Art cannot be defined" because it is an "Open Concept" that is always changing.
• Readymade — An "Ordinary Object" (like a bicycle wheel) that an artist "Selects" and "Names" as art.

Understanding

Theories of art are understood through Intent and Context.

1. The "Message" (Expressionism): Why do we feel "Sad" when we look at a painting of a "Blue Square"?

• Tolstoy argued that art is a "Bridge" of feeling.
• The artist feels **X**, puts it into the **Object**, and the audience feels **X**.
• If "No Emotion" is transmitted, it's just "Decoration," not "Art."
• Art is the "Language of the Soul."

2. The "Setting" (Institutional Theory): Why is a "Urinal" in a "Museum" art, but a "Urinal" in a "Bathroom" not?

• Arthur Danto argued that the **"Art World"** (the context) "Transforms" the object.
• By "Putting it in a Gallery," the artist is saying: "Look at this as a set of symbols, not as a tool."
• Art is a **Social Label**. We "Vote" on what is art through our institutions.

3. The "Significant Form" (Formalism): Does art need a "Story"?

• Formalists say **"No."**
• A "Beautiful Rug" or a "Symphony" has no "Story," but it has **"Form."**
• The "Harmony of Colors" and "Balance of Lines" create an "Aesthetic Emotion" that is separate from real life.
• Art is "Pure Pattern."

The 'Brillo Box' (1964)': Andy Warhol made wooden boxes that looked "Exactly" like real Brillo soap boxes. Philosopher Arthur Danto realized that since they were "Visually Identical," the "Art-ness" must be "Invisible." It must be in the **Theory** and the **History** of the object. This ended the idea that art is about "How things look."

Applying

Modeling 'The Art Test' (Checking an object against 'Cluster Theory' traits): <syntaxhighlight lang="python"> def is_it_art_cluster(traits):

   """
   Art is a 'Cluster' of things. You don't need all of them.
   """
   points = 0
   if "Intentional" in traits: points += 1
   if "Aesthetic Experience" in traits: points += 1
   if "Creative/Imaginary" in traits: points += 1
   if "High Skill" in traits: points += 1
   if "Social/Museum Context" in traits: points += 1
   
   if points >= 3:
       return "RESULT: YES. It has enough 'Cluster Traits' to be called Art."
   else:
       return "RESULT: DEBATABLE. It might just be a 'Craft' or an 'Object'."

1. Case: A child's drawing (Intentional, Creative, but Low Skill)

print(is_it_art_cluster(["Intentional", "Creative/Imaginary"]))

1. Case: A Masterpiece (All traits)

print(is_it_art_cluster(["Intentional", "Aesthetic Experience", "Creative/Imaginary", "High Skill", "Social/Museum Context"])) </syntaxhighlight>

Art Landmarks

The 'Fountain' (1917) → Duchamp's urinal: the "Big Bang" of modern art theory that "Proved" that "Anything" can be art if an artist says it is.

Tolstoy’s 'What is Art?' (1897) → A fierce attack on "Elite Art," arguing that "Simple Folk Songs" are "Better Art" because they "Communicate" to everyone.

Clive Bell’s 'Significant Form' → The foundation of "Abstract Art" (Kandinsky/Mondrian), freeing art from the "Burden" of "Looking like things."

The 'NFT' Boom → The modern "Institutional" battle: is a "Digital File" art? (If the 'Internet Community' says 'Yes' and pays millions, does that 'Make' it art?).

Analyzing

Four Main Theories of Art

Theory	Core Idea	Analogy
Mimesis	Art is a "Mirror" of Nature	A 'Photograph'
Expressionism	Art is a "Transfusion" of Emotion	A 'Scream' or 'Laugh'
Formalism	Art is a "Pattern" of Forms	A 'Snowflake' or 'Persian Rug'
Institutional	Art is a "Place" in the Gallery	A 'Title' or 'Crown'

The Concept of "Open Concept": Analyzing "The Future." Morris Weitz argued that any "Definition" of art will eventually be "Broken" by a "New Artist." Art is "Inherently Creative," which means it "Must" break the rules. To "Define" art is to "Kill" it. We should only look for "Family Resemblances" between old art and new art.

Evaluating

Evaluating theories of art:

1. The "Skill" Question: If "Anything" can be art, is the "Mastery" of a painter (like Rembrandt) "Wasted"? (Is 'Art' becoming too 'Easy'?).
2. Elitism: If the "Art World" decides what is art, does that give "Too much power" to "Rich Critics" and "Snobs"?
3. AI Art: If an "AI" has "No Soul" and "No Emotion," can its "Output" be called "Art"? (Can there be 'Expression' without an 'Expressor'?).
4. Video Games: Are "Video Games" the "Complete Art Form" (mixing Music, Visuals, and Action), or are they just "Entertainment"?

Creating

Future Frontiers:

1. The 'Algorithmic' Art Definition: An AI that "Calculates the Art-ness" of an object by "Mapping" its "Innovation" against the "History of Human Style."
2. Generative 'Institutional' Markets: A "DAO" (Decentralized Autonomous Organization) where "The Whole Internet" votes on "What is Art," taking power away from the "Gallerists."
3. Personalized Art Simulations: A VR world that "Creates Art" specifically to "Match Your Personal Aesthetics," redefining art as a "Personal Therapeutic tool."
4. Biological Art: Using "DNA" and "Living Cells" to create "Sculptures that Grow," forcing a "New Theory" of art that includes "Life."