Agency and Intentionality

How to read this page: This article maps the topic from beginner to expert across six levels � Remembering, Understanding, Applying, Analyzing, Evaluating, and Creating. Scan the headings to see the full scope, then read from wherever your knowledge starts to feel uncertain. Learn more about how BloomWiki works ?

Agency and Intentionality is the "Study of the Doer"—the investigation of what it "Means" to "Act" rather than just "Move." While a "Rock" moves because it is "Pushed," a "Human" moves because they "Intend" to. From **Elizabeth Anscombe's** "Intention" (the foundation of the field) to the "Donald Davidson" theory of "Reasons as Causes" and the "Basic Actions" of the body, this field explores the "Spark of the Will." It is the science of "Purpose," explaining why "Tripping and Falling" is an "Event," while "Jumping" is an "Action."

Remembering

• Agency — The "Capacity" of an entity (an Agent) to "Act" in any given environment.
• Intentionality — The "About-ness" of the mind: the fact that our "Actions" are "Directed toward a goal."
• Action Theory — The branch of philosophy that explores the "Nature" of actions and the "Reasons" behind them.
• Intentional Action — An action done "With a specific purpose" in mind (e.g., 'I am drinking water because I am thirsty').
• Basic Action — An action you do "Directly" without doing anything else first (e.g., 'Moving your arm').
• Practical Reason — The "Process" of "Deciding what to do" (e.g., 'I want to be healthy, so I will eat an apple').
• Reasons-as-Causes (Davidson) — The influential idea that your "Reason" for acting (your desire + belief) is the "Physical Cause" of your body moving.
• The Wayward Causal Chain — A "Logic Problem": what if you "Intend" to do something, but it happens "By Accident" because you got "Nervous"? (Is it still an 'Action'?).
• Teleology — The explanation of phenomena by the "Purpose they serve" rather than by "Prior Causes."
• Agent Causation — The idea that "Agents" can "Start new chains of cause-and-effect" that weren't determined by the past.

Understanding

Agency and intentionality are understood through Goal-Direction and Reasons.

1. The "Why" (Intentionality): How do we "Identify" an action?

• G.E.M. Anscombe asked: "What is the difference between your arm rising and you **Raising** your arm?"
• The difference is **Intent**.
• If I am "Raising my arm" to "Ask a question," the "Ask a Question" is the "Intention."
• If my arm "Rises" because of a "Muscle Spasm," it is not an "Action."
• "Action" is "Movements with a Story."

2. The "Engine" of Action (Belief + Desire): Most philosophers use the **Belief-Desire Model**.

• I have a **Desire**: "I want to be in London."
• I have a **Belief**: "The train goes to London."
• Therefore, I have a **Reason** to "Buy a ticket."
• This "Logic" is what "Turns a Thought" into a "Physical Movement."

3. The "Chain" of Doing (Basic Actions): Everything you do is a "Chain."

• "Saving the World" (Goal) -> "Voting" (Action) -> "Moving a Pen" (Basic Action).
• You "Do" the big things **By** "Doing" the small things.
• Agency is the "Ladder" that links our "Highest Hopes" to our "Fingertips."

The 'Nervous Assassin' Problem': A man intends to "Shoot the king" to save his country. He gets so "Nervous" that his "Finger Twitches" and "Shoots the king." Did he "Act"? He had the **Intention** and he caused the **Result**, but the "Chain" was "Broken" by nervousness. Most philosophers say this is **Not** an intentional action. It proves that "Agency" requires "Control" over the "Path" from mind to hand.

Applying

Modeling 'The Agency Test' (Determining if a movement was an 'Action'): <syntaxhighlight lang="python"> def is_it_an_action(was_intended, had_control, followed_the_plan):

   """
   Shows the 'Strength' of Agency.
   """
   if was_intended and had_control and followed_the_plan:
       return "RESULT: FULL AGENCY. (An Intentional Action)."
   elif was_intended and not followed_the_plan:
       return "RESULT: WAYWARD ACTION. (A 'Lucky' accident or a failure)."
   elif not was_intended:
       return "RESULT: EVENT. (A mere 'Movement' or reflex)."
   else:
       return "RESULT: DIMINISHED AGENCY."

1. Case: You meant to throw the ball, and you did.

print(is_it_an_action(True, True, True))

1. Case: You meant to throw it, but you tripped and it fell into the hoop.

print(is_it_an_action(True, False, False)) </syntaxhighlight>

Agency Landmarks

The 'Anscombe' Revolution (1957) → Her book *Intention* proved that "Action" is not a "Feeling in the head," but a "Way of Being" in the world.

AI Agency → Can a "Robot" have "Intentionality"? (If a robot 'Intends' to 'Clean the floor,' is it 'Acting' or just 'Following Code'?).

Akrasia (Weakness of Will) → When you "Intend" to do **X** (e.g. 'Study'), but you "Do" **Y** (e.g. 'Watch TV'). It is the "Glitch" in human agency.

Libet’s Experiment → A brain scan that showed the "Brain Starts Moving" **before** the person "Decides to move." It raised the terrifying question: "Is Agency an Illusion?"

Analyzing

Event vs. Action

Feature	Event (The Wind Blowing)	Action (You Blowing a Candle)
Source	"External" Physics	"Internal" Intention
Explanation	"Cause and Effect"	"Reasons and Goals"
Responsibility	None	Full (Moral/Legal)
Direction	One-way (Past -> Future)	Two-way (Goal -> Movement)
Analogy	A 'Falling Rock'	A 'Guided Missile'

The Concept of "Descriptions of Action": Analyzing "The Label." The **same movement** (moving a pen) can be described as "Scribbling," "Writing a Name," or "Signing a Death Warrant." Our "Agency" depends on "Which Description" we "Intend." You are "Doing" what you "Think" you are doing.

Evaluating

Evaluating agency and intentionality:

1. Addiction: Does an "Addict" have "Full Agency"? (If their 'Brain' forces them to act against their 'Will,' who is the 'Agent'?).
2. Coercion: If someone "Holds a Gun to your Head," are you still an "Agent"? (You 'Intend' to give the money, but is it 'Your' intention?).
3. AI: If an "Autonomous AI" makes a "Mistake," who is the "Agent"? (The 'Programmer,' the 'AI,' or 'No one'?).
4. Dementia: How do we "Respect the Agency" of someone who "Forgets their intentions" every minute?

Creating

Future Frontiers:

1. Agency-Enhancing Implants: A "Neural Chip" that helps people with "Weak Will" (Akrasia) stay "Focused" on their "Long-term Intentions."
2. Legal 'AI Agent' Status: A "New Law" that gives "Autonomous Systems" a "Limited Agency," making them "Responsible" for their "Intentional Calculations."
3. Collaborative 'Hive' Agency: A system where "1,000 People" can "Share a single Intention" via a "Neural Link," creating a "Super-Agent" that can "Act" as a single unit.
4. The 'Agency' Audit: A tool that "Scans your life" and "Shows" how many of your "Actions" are "Truly yours" vs. how many are "Habit" or "Social Pressure."